← Blog

Self-compassion is the hardest part

On the place of compassion in the treatment of borderline personality disorder, drawing on a chapter published in 2024.

For a long time borderline personality disorder (BPD) was considered hard to treat, even untreatable, until specific psychotherapies were developed, such as dialectical behaviour therapy, mentalisation-based therapy, schema therapy and transference-focused therapy, which according to the evidence we reviewed have shown greater efficacy than standard treatment. In clinical practice, however, some people do not fit protocol-based therapeutic processes, or they are at a point in life that calls for strengthening aspects those therapies do not focus on, as happens when strong self-criticism or shame about the symptoms persists. Together with Gerardo Rivera, Jaime Yáñez-Lizana and Álvaro Langer, I wrote a chapter, published by Pirámide in 2024, in which we explored what interventions based on compassion and self-compassion can offer in those cases (Fuentes-Ferrada et al., 2024).

Two models for the same difficulty

The analysis draws on the two models that organise much of the literature. The first is compassion-focused therapy, which describes emotion regulation systems such as threat and soothing, and understands much suffering as an imbalance between them (Gilbert, 2009). The second is Kristin Neff’s model of self-compassion, made up of three dimensions (self-kindness, common humanity and mindfulness) whose opposite poles are self-criticism, isolation and over-identification. Applied to BPD, both models suggest that the soothing system may be particularly disrupted, which fits the studies we reviewed on lower oxytocin levels in these people and on their aversion to giving and receiving compassion. The three dimensions of self-compassion also tend to appear at low levels, while their opposite poles show up more severely.

What the case showed

The chapter rests on the experience of a 48-year-old client who was receiving standard treatment in a public psychiatric service and who, alongside it, took part in compassion-based interventions in several formats. What we observed comes down to two effects. On the one hand, compassion seems to open up self-absorption, making it easier to understand the other and to receive their care, which lowers the sense of threat in interpersonal interaction. On the other, self-compassion practices seem to strengthen both the capacity to step back from the contents of consciousness in moments of crisis and the capacity to find relief in common humanity. Self-kindness, in contrast, appears to be the dimension that requires the most effort. She put it better than we could: «Self-compassion is what I find hardest, harder than compassion, hard in the sense of accepting that I’m not well, that I have to be more patient».

In one of the first studies on the subject, the association between compassion for others and self-compassion was significant only in a group of meditators, and not in university students or community adults (Neff & Pommier, 2013). The difference the client describes has, in our view, at least two explanations. First, the two forms of compassion do not seem to be necessarily related, so a compassionate relationship with others cannot be assumed to imply a compassionate relationship with oneself. Second, the core of self-compassion is emotional self-regulation (reducing distressing emotions and increasing positive ones), and emotional dysregulation is precisely the central feature of BPD. Asking a person with this diagnosis for self-compassion therefore means asking for extra effort in what costs them most, which calls for graded practices and for not reading the difficulty as resistance.

Considerations for the clinic

I still think that compassion for others and self-compassion can be part of BPD treatment, provided that each person’s history and clinical course are taken into account, since this diagnosis is less stable over time than is often believed. One possible reading, which the case suggests even though a single case does not allow us to generalise it, is that compassion for others and common humanity are more accessible ways in, while self-kindness takes longer. There is something in that order that seems clinically relevant to me, and also human. Many people learn to treat themselves with care after having been treated with care by others, and therapy can be one of the places where that happens.

References

Fuentes-Ferrada, R., Rivera, G., Yáñez-Lizana, J., & Langer, Á. I. (2024). Terapia centrada en la compasión y autocompasión en el trastorno límite de la personalidad. In Tratamientos psicológicos en los trastornos de la personalidad (pp. 169-181). Pirámide.

Gilbert, P. (2009). Introducing compassion-focused therapy. Advances in Psychiatric Treatment, 15(3), 199-208. https://doi.org/10.1192/apt.bp.107.005264

Neff, K. D., & Pommier, E. (2013). The relationship between self-compassion and other-focused concern among college undergraduates, community adults, and practicing meditators. Self and Identity, 12(2), 160-176. https://doi.org/10.1080/15298868.2011.649546

reinerfuentes7@gmail.com

Write to me

What would you like to talk about?