When faith also hurts
Religious coping, experiential avoidance and self-compassion during the pandemic, drawing on a study with 300 adults in Chile.
Religiosity usually appears in the literature as a factor that helps people face adversity, and during the COVID-19 pandemic it was an important resource for many. The relationship with the sacred, however, is not always a place of rest. Negative religious coping, also called spiritual struggle, gathers the strategies that reflect tension, conflict or struggle with the sacred (Pargament et al., 2011), such as feeling punished or abandoned by God in the middle of a crisis. Together with two colleagues, I asked how this form of coping related to post-traumatic stress linked to the pandemic, and which psychological processes might be mediating that relationship (Fuentes-Ferrada et al., 2022).
The study
To answer, we ran an online survey with 300 adults living in Chile, in a cross-sectional design with a convenience sample, and included two processes that contextual psychology has studied extensively. The first is experiential avoidance (the tendency to control or avoid unwanted thoughts, emotions and sensations). The second is self-compassion, understood as the affective quality with which a person relates to themselves, especially when they suffer or make mistakes. Our hypothesis was that both processes would mediate, one after the other, the relationship between negative religious coping and post-traumatic stress, which in statistical terms is called serial mediation.
The results showed that all the variables were related to one another, and that people who used negative religious coping and were less compassionate towards themselves had more symptoms of post-traumatic stress (Fuentes-Ferrada et al., 2022). The serial mediation also held, since greater experiential avoidance and lower self-compassion, in sequence, mediated the relationship between spiritual struggle and stress. One result deserves attention. Experiential avoidance did not mediate that relationship on its own, even though it was significantly and positively associated with post-traumatic stress; it did so only together with self-compassion.
Two ways of reading it
One possible explanation has to do with time. Experiential avoidance works as a maladaptive strategy in both the short and the long term, while spiritual struggle, although associated with psychological distress in the moment, could also open a possibility for learning, growth and transformation (Pargament et al., 2011). Not every tension with the sacred, then, amounts to an avoidant style. The other explanation still strikes me as the most suggestive part of the work. Experiential avoidance describes how we relate to the contents of consciousness, and self-compassion describes how we relate to ourselves. Both relationships could be analogous to the one we establish with the sacred, so that someone who lives their faith through conflict would also tend to fight their inner experience and to treat themselves harshly.
These observations have limited but concrete clinical implications. For people who use maladaptive religious strategies, it may help to offer interventions that reduce experiential avoidance and strengthen self-compassion, such as mindfulness-based approaches or acceptance and commitment therapy, without this implying any intervention on their beliefs. The cross-sectional design does not allow causal relationships to be established, and a convenience sample limits how far the results can be generalised, so the proposed sequence should be read as a plausible model that needs longitudinal studies to be confirmed.
What it left me with
This work belongs to a line of research on religiosity and mental health that I have pursued for several years, and that has taught me to distrust two simplifications, the one that treats faith as a protective factor and nothing more, and the one that reduces it to a symptom. What matters for a person’s mental health is what they believe and also the way they relate to it, even when that relationship goes through moments of conflict. In the consulting room, asking about that relationship with the same care we bring to family bonds often opens conversations that would otherwise stay outside the therapeutic process.
References
Fuentes-Ferrada, R., Cerda-Planas, C., & Fernández, M. B. (2022). Religious coping, experiential avoidance, self-compassion, and post-traumatic stress by COVID-19: A serial mediation study. International Journal of Latin American Religions, 7(2), 562-573. https://doi.org/10.1007/s41603-022-00184-4
Pargament, K., Feuille, M., & Burdzy, D. (2011). The Brief RCOPE: Current psychometric status of a short measure of religious coping. Religions, 2(1), 51-76. https://doi.org/10.3390/rel2010051